Case study · New York State Destination Marketing Organizations
One campaign. Twenty-three destinations. One voice.
A statewide outdoor recreation campaign that organized New York around how a trip feels rather than where it happens, and grew conversions 1,711 percent year over year.
Client
New York State Destination Marketing Organizations
Scope
Brand development, creative services, digital marketing, marketing management
Term
Two years, 2024 and 2025, with equal visibility for every partner
Headline result
Conversions up 1,711 percent year over year
The challenge
NYSDMO promotes outdoor recreation across a broad and diverse portfolio, from New York City to the Adirondacks, the Finger Lakes, and Long Island. The task was to elevate perception of the state as a whole while keeping each region's distinct outdoor experience legible. Unify too hard and the individual destinations disappear. Unify too little and there is no statewide story at all.
The strategy
Travelers do not plan by county line. They plan by what they want the weekend to feel like. So we organized the campaign by mood instead of geography, then mapped destinations to the mood. Travelers picked a vibe, and the vibe picked the places.
The creative
The vibe was never just a headline. It ran through the ad sets, the targeting, and the structure of the microsite, so every partner got creative that matched the traveler rather than the county, and every partner appeared in the work rather than a favored few.
How it worked
In a co-op this size, the first question in every board room is why them and not us. We answered it in the media buy, not in the meeting. Every partner received a fair share of visibility across the microsite, the creative, and the paid spend, and we could show each of them exactly where their share went.
A centralized hub carried the unified NYSDMO brand and gave every destination a place inside a campaign far bigger than its own budget could buy.
We rotated partners through featured placement by hand rather than letting an algorithm or an alphabet decide. No destination sat permanently at the bottom of a list, and every one of them cycled through the positions travelers actually see.
Our method for distributing paid spend across competing partners, so allocation is editorial and defensible rather than political. Share of impressions and clicks was tracked by destination, which meant fairness was something we could prove to a board rather than assert.
Equal visibility surfaced something we did not expect. The lesser-known destinations were converting at a higher rate than the marquee names, so we moved media weight and creative placement toward them. Equal representation was the starting point, and the performance data told us where to lean in from there.
We retargeted warm audiences, concentrating spend on the travelers most likely to make the trip, and pointed them to the campaign's trip planning resources so the brand stayed with them while they worked out where to go.
Results
14,631 goal completions at a 5.23 percent conversion rate, across a portfolio of more than twenty destinations.
Year over year: clicks up 25 percent, click-through rate up 152 percent, conversion rate up 1,339 percent.
What we learned
A two year commitment gave the campaign runway to learn. Every quarter of data made the targeting sharper and the creative smarter, so performance compounded instead of plateauing. A one year pilot would never have gotten here.
We rotated partners through the microsite by hand so every destination got a real share of the spotlight, and we tracked share of impressions and clicks by partner so fairness could be proven rather than promised. That work surfaced something we did not expect: the lesser-known destinations were winning. So we followed it, and moved media and creative placement toward them.
Everything is not the same. Segmenting the ad sets, the targeting, and the microsite around what outdoor recreation actually means to an individual traveler took more work, and it is exactly where the return came from.
One shared brand and one shared hub gave the group a statewide footprint no single budget could reach. That is the actual return on collaborating, and it is the thing to protect when the negotiating starts.
Work with us
We build campaigns that hold a group together without flattening anyone in it. If that is the problem on your desk, we should talk.
Start a conversation
hellopaperkite.com ·
hello@hellopaperkite.com ·
607 282 4223
175 Main Street, Cooperstown, New York 13326